3-Step Critical Analysis
Step 1: Describe
- Identify the key arguments or perspectives on your topic.
- Explain what is being argued, for and against.
- Highlight evidence used to support the arguments.
- Identify the assumptions underlying the arguments.
Step 2: Interpret
- Understand the meanings and implications of the arguments.
- Consider who might agree or disagree and why.
- Analyze the impact of the arguments on people, organizations, or issues.
Step 3: Evaluate
- Judge the strength and value of each argument or perspective.
- Assess whether the supporting evidence withstands scrutiny.
- Identify what or who the argument fails to consider.
- Evaluate the relevance and usefulness of the arguments for the topic.